Advertisements

So you wanna build a wall?

There’s been a lot of conversation around a certain wall over past couple years that may or may not be built along a specific border next to a specific country. It’s a controversial subject, to put it lightly. Now, I’ve been finding myself confused by the information that’s been circulating. There are a lot of numbers being presented, be it wall costs, immigrant populations, and costs of undocumented immigrants to the United States government. So, I’ve taken it upon myself to break down the numbers and get to the bottom of what is the wall.

As for the estimates of the wall, the number varies greatly depending on who they’re coming from. Donnie Trump estimates the cost is around $15 billion, a price it appears that most Republicans agree with. Democratic senators believe that the cost to build the wall will actually be $70 billion, and $150 million per year in maintenance. The third estimate in an op-ed from Fox News puts the price tag closer to $25 billion but also emphasizes that only includes the cost to build the said wall and not on the economic impact a wall could have, be it positive or negative. There are also other factors that could complicate the building of the wall, such as lawsuits over property, the sheer area of the wall, and areas requiring potential landscaping in order to be suitable for the construction of the wall.

So we now have three estimates to go off of: $15 billion, $25 billion, and $70 billion. Now, we must establish the cost of illegal immigrants to the United States government. That’s easier said than done, as this data is difficult to find without some sort of bias in place, as well as contributions immigrants make to the economy, which is an estimated $11.6 billion. The most reliable was an estimate of $54 billion, which the article states as difficult to determine a precise number.

In order to more likely represent the numbers that are being used, we have to adjust the number of immigrants to those that are Mexican, as the point of the wall is to limit migrants coming from the southern border. Of the immigrants who have come to, 50% of them come from Mexico. So, we’ll make some assumptions here and say that Mexican immigrants cost the government around $27 billion, and contribute roughly $5.8 billion to the economy. I also feel obligated to mention that while immigrants do cost the government money, as do normal Americans, although I wasn’t able to determine if the costs are more or less.

Now that we have some rough estimates of costs, it’s time to tackle some of the other claims that have been made, specifically referring to the claims that “when Mexico sends their people, they’re not sending us their best,” as stated by our President Donnie Trump, as well as later going on to state in that same speech “They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing criminals. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people. ” So there were some accusations made that I’ll have to address now.

Now, I cannot make judgments as to the characters of immigrants, but I can look into the claims that have been made. While he is correct that most illegal drugs are trafficked in from Mexico, they have typically moved through Ports of Entry, and a wall would likely have little to no impact on the drug trade. Of the estimated 11 million immigrants that live in the United States, about 820,000 have some prior criminal conviction, which is equal to roughly 7%. Of the 11 million, only about 300,000 carry a prior felony conviction, which is less than 3% of the population. As for the allegation that rapists are coming in, there tend to be more difficulties with finding data, as it’s much similar to a Bigfoot sighting; often claimed but rarely ever accurate. From some data I was able to find out of Texas, only about .03% of all convictions were sex crimes related to illegal immigrants.  As can be seen, these claims tend to be exaggerated in favor of building support.

As we’ve broken down the information and potentially risked my social standing in my small town, it’s pretty easy to see that there’s a lot to address when looking at something such as a wall. I’m admittedly not a supporter of the wall for a great many reasons, mostly from an ethical background but also a financial inclination that the problem it seeks to fix won’t have enough impact to justify such an expensive and prolonged plan. I’m interested to see what everyone else thinks so feel free to sound off in a mature conversation.

In the Circle

Advertisements

jordyscircle View All →

Hello! My name is Jordan but you can call me Jordy! I'm an aspiring young writer/creator who focuses primarily on video arts such as movies and video games, as well as anything else that catches my attention. I'm a pretty mellow, introverted guy but I welcome conversation so feel free to reach out! Thank you for taking the time to read this!

2 Comments Leave a comment

  1. No offense intended but I do find your numbers a bit too skewed.

    According to several .Gov websites in 2017 alone Illegal Migrants(Including People who overstayed their visas as well as those who crossed illegally) cost the US government and citizens approximately 131 Billion USD in 2017 alone. They do contribute about 18 billion back to us but that pales in comparison to the cost. And while maintaining a wall may cost a pretty penny it creates more jobs for American citizens and could potentially help bolster the economy. From this math the $150 Million USD it would take from your very generous estimate to maintain the border wall would never begin to compare to the amount of money we lose every year.
    My source is unfortunately Third Party but it lists a little over 50 first party government statistics on the cost of illegal immigration. 150 Million is nowhere near a Single Billion USD. If the border wall could only stop 10% of illegal immigration for the immigrants who do cross illegally we would still save a small fortune of money that would pay for the wall. Illegal immigration costs us far too much to do nothing. On average Illegal Immigrants who enter the country by crossing illegally make up about 40% of all Illegal immigrants. 40% of the total cost was approximately 53.4 Billion USD in 2017. If the wall prevents 10% of that 53.4 Billion cost per year, the wall will effectively pay for itself eventually. 150Million USD vs 5.24Billion(Effectively 5240Million) is a more than reasonable and cost effective solution than it first appears. And that is if the wall could only stop 10% of ground crossings, if it could prevent 80%(Which many argue it could but these are theories) we would most likely pay for the wall in a year or two after building it.

    I highly recommend this Read(It’s my Third Party Source with 50+ First Party sources listed)
    https://fairus.org/sites/default/files/2017-09/Fiscal-Burden-of-Illegal-Immigration-2017.pdf

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: